The evidence includes Kerberos pre-authentication failure indicators, often associated with stale credentials, wrong password material, or account synchronization timing.
Recommended remediation
Collect klist output, confirm the user can obtain a fresh TGT, and retest after full sign-out/sign-in.
Sample evidence
Event ID 4768 detected
Result Code 0x18 detected
2
Possible Kerberos SPN mismatch or missing SPN
HIGHHIGH confidence
The evidence suggests the service ticket request may be failing because the HTTP SPN is missing or registered to an old hostname.
Recommended remediation
Run setspn -Q for the exact service hostname, check duplicate SPNs, and align the app URL with the service account SPN.
Sample evidence
Service Name: HTTP/finance-app.example.edu
No such SPN found: HTTP/finance-app.example.edu
3
Authorization denied due to missing group
HIGHHIGH confidence
The app authorization log indicates the user authenticated but was denied because the expected AD group was missing.
Recommended remediation
Confirm required group, current memberOf values, nested-group handling, and whether the user refreshed their session after group changes.
Sample evidence
Required group: Finance-App-Users
Observed groups: Finance-App-ReadOnly, VPN-Users
Sample Generated Report
Troubleshooting narrative
Executive Summary
The Windows/AD evidence suggests several access-layer issues: stale credential signs, possible Kerberos SPN misconfiguration, and missing application authorization group membership.
Most Likely Root Cause
The user may be hitting both authentication and authorization problems. Kerberos evidence points to possible SPN or stale credential issues, while application logs indicate the user lacks the required AD group.
Recommended Next Step
Collect klist output, setspn query results, current AD memberOf values, and application authorization logs around the failed timestamp.